

投资性资产,还是消费性资产?
Investment Asset OR Consumption Asset ?
| 交易期货的交易所 | 交易期权的交易所 |
|---|---|
| 芝加哥期货交易所 (CBOT,1865 年) | 芝加哥期权交易所 (CBOE) |
| 芝加哥商业交易所 (CME) | 费城证券交易所 |
| LIFFE(伦敦国际金融期货交易所,伦敦) | LIFFE(伦敦) |
| Eurex(欧洲期货交易所,欧洲) | Eurex(欧洲) |
| SFE(悉尼期货交易所) 1960 年首笔交易(羊毛期货) 2002 年在 ASX 上市 | ASX(澳大利亚证券交易所) 1976 年首笔期权交易(BHP 看涨期权) 1982 年首批看跌期权 |
| Exchanges Trading Futures | Exchanges Trading Options |
|---|---|
| Chicago Board of Trade (1865) | Chicago Board Options Exchange |
| Chicago Mercantile Exchange | Philadelphia Stock Exchange |
| LIFFE (London) | LIFFE (London) |
| Eurex (Europe) | Eurex (Europe) |
| SFE (Sydney) 1st trade in 1960 (Wool futures) Listed on ASX: 2002 | ASX 1st options trade in 1976 (BHP calls) 1st put options in 1982 |
资料来源:国际清算银行 (BIS)。图中场外市场为名义本金总额,交易所市场为基础资产价值。
Source: Bank for International Settlements. Chart shows total principal amounts for OTC markets and value of underlying assets for exchange markets.
远期合约是一种场外 (OTC) 协议,约定在未来某一时间
A forward contract is an OTC agreement to buy or sell an asset at a certain time
期货合约是一种协议,约定在未来某一时间
A futures contract is an agreement to buy or sell an asset at a certain time
| 比较维度 | 远期合约 (Forward Contract) | 期货合约 (Futures Contract) |
|---|---|---|
| 交易场所 | 场外交易市场 OTC (私下双边协商) | 规范化交易所 (如 CME、ASX、ICE) |
| 合约条款 | 根据用户个性化需求量身定制 | 高度标准化 (规模、交割品、日期) |
| 结算方式 | 到期日 |
每日结算 (逐日盯市 Mark to Market) |
| 信用风险 | 存在显著的交易对手违约风险 | 由结算所清算担保,基本被消除 |
| 提前平仓 | 较为困难;需征得原对手方同意 | 在流动性充裕的市场上随时对冲平仓 |
核心机制总结: 期货利用结算所保证金制度替代了个体交易对手信用风险。由于每日损益都在当日现金结算结清,违约敞口无法像双边远期协议那样跨越数月累积扩大。
| Dimension | Forward Contract | Futures Contract |
|---|---|---|
| Trading Arena | Over-The-Counter (private bilateral) | Organised Exchange (CME, ASX, ICE) |
| Contract Terms | Customised to user needs | Standardised (size, delivery, date) |
| Settlement | Single settlement at maturity |
Marked to market daily |
| Credit Risk | Significant counterparty risk | Virtually eliminated by Clearinghouse |
| Closing Out | Difficult; requires counterparty consent | Immediate offset in liquid market |
Futures replace individual counterparty risk with clearinghouse margin capital. Because gains and losses are realized daily, default exposure cannot accumulate across months as it does in bilateral forward agreements.
随着时间推移,市场参与者持续交易在
注意
As time goes by, market participants continue trading futures contracts to buy/sell the asset at
Note that
| 日期 | 期货价格 ($) | 当日盈亏 ($) | 累计盈亏 ($) | 保证金账户余额 ($) | 追加保证金 ($) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 400.00 | 4,000 | ||||
| 6月5日 | 397.00 | (600) = 2 × $3 × 100 盎司 | (600) | 3,400 | |
| 6月6日 | 396.10 | (180) | (780) | 3,220 | |
| 6月9日 | 398.20 | 420 | (360) | 3,640 | |
| 6月10日 | 397.10 | (220) | (580) | 3,420 | |
| 6月11日 | 396.70 | (80) | (660) | 3,340 | |
| 6月12日 | 395.40 | (260) | (920) | 3,080 | |
| 6月13日 | 393.30 | (420) | (1,340) | 2,660 | 1,340 |
| 6月16日 | 393.60 | 60 | (1,280) | 4,060 | |
| 6月17日 | 391.80 | (360) | (1,640) | 3,700 | |
| 6月18日 | 392.70 | 180 | (1,460) | 3,880 | |
| 6月19日 | 387.00 | (1,140) | (2,600) | 2,740 | 1,260 |
| 6月20日 | 387.00 | 0 | (2,600) | 4,000 | |
| 6月23日 | 388.10 | 220 | (2,380) | 4,220 | |
| 6月24日 | 388.70 | 120 | (2,260) | 4,340 | |
| 6月25日 | 391.00 | 460 | (1,800) | 4,800 | |
| 6月26日 | 392.30 | 260 | (1,540) | 5,060 |
| Day | Futures Price ($) | Daily Gain (Loss) ($) | Cumulative Gain (Loss) ($) | Margin Account Balance ($) | Margin Call ($) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 400.00 | 4,000 | ||||
| June 5 | 397.00 | (600) = 2 × $3 × 100 oz | (600) | 3,400 | |
| June 6 | 396.10 | (180) | (780) | 3,220 | |
| June 9 | 398.20 | 420 | (360) | 3,640 | |
| June 10 | 397.10 | (220) | (580) | 3,420 | |
| June 11 | 396.70 | (80) | (660) | 3,340 | |
| June 12 | 395.40 | (260) | (920) | 3,080 | |
| June 13 | 393.30 | (420) | (1,340) | 2,660 | 1,340 |
| June 16 | 393.60 | 60 | (1,280) | 4,060 | |
| June 17 | 391.80 | (360) | (1,640) | 3,700 | |
| June 18 | 392.70 | 180 | (1,460) | 3,880 | |
| June 19 | 387.00 | (1,140) | (2,600) | 2,740 | 1,260 |
| June 20 | 387.00 | 0 | (2,600) | 4,000 | |
| June 23 | 388.10 | 220 | (2,380) | 4,220 | |
| June 24 | 388.70 | 120 | (2,260) | 4,340 | |
| June 25 | 391.00 | 460 | (1,800) | 4,800 | |
| June 26 | 392.30 | 260 | (1,540) | 5,060 |
参数设定: 交易者 A 以 2,800 点买入多头 1 张 E-Mini S&P 500 期货合约。合约乘数 = $50/指数点。名义价值 =
初始保证金 = $5,500 • 维持保证金 = $5,000 • 账户初始资金 = $5,500。
重要区分: 投资者必须注入 $750 将账户余额恢复至 初始保证金 $5,500,而绝不能只追加 $250 恢复到维持保证金!
Contract Parameters (from video): Trader A goes LONG 1 E-Mini S&P 500 contract at 2,800. Multiplier = $50/point. Notional value =
Initial Margin = $5,500 • Maintenance Margin = $5,000 • Starting balance = $5,500.
Critical Distinction: The investor must deposit $750 to bring the balance back to the initial margin of $5,500, NOT merely $250 to reach maintenance margin!
黄金和 E-Mini 两个例子的价格都已填好。点“重置”后逐日点“下一天”,看余额怎么变;把某一天的价格改低,让余额跌破维持保证金,注意追加的钱补回的是初始保证金。 新窗口全屏打开 ↗
Click “Reset”, then “Next day” to step through the gold and E-Mini examples. Lower a price until the balance triggers a margin call: the deposit restores the initial margin. Open in New Window ↗
远期曲线给出某一天不同到期期限的期货价格。
| 黄金 (GOLD) | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 合约 | 月份 | 最新价 | 涨跌 | 开盘 | 最高 | 最低 | 成交量 | 持仓量 | 交易所 |
| 黄金 | 2011年7月 | 1612.0y | 67 | 40 | COMX | ||||
| 黄金 | 2011年8月 | 1614.9 | 2.7 | 1614.8 | 1615.5 | 1611.1 | 12261 | 193611 | COMX |
| 黄金 | 2011年9月 | 1615.6 | 2.7 | 1614.3 | 1616.1 | 1612.9 | 62 | 9255 | COMX |
| 黄金 | 2011年10月 | 1615.8 | 2.5 | 1616.1 | 1616.4 | 1612.8 | 166 | 17547 | COMX |
| 黄金 | 2011年12月 | 1617.3 | 2.9 | 1616.1 | 1617.7 | 1613.4 | 4876 | 216137 | COMX |
| 黄金 | 2012年2月 | 1617.5 | 1.7 | 1618.0 | 1618.0 | 1617.5 | 19 | 11520 | COMX |
| 黄金 | 2012年4月 | 1619.4 | 2.1 | 1616.7 | 1619.4 | 1616.7 | 4 | 6165 | COMX |
图:2011 年 7 月 25 日 COMEX 黄金期货合约行情(来源:ifs.marketcenter.com)
The forward curve gives the futures prices on a given day, for a range of different maturities.
| GOLD | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contract | Month | Last | Chg | Open | High | Low | Volume | OpenInt | Exchange |
| GOLD | Jul '11 | 1612.0y | 67 | 40 | COMX | ||||
| GOLD | Aug '11 | 1614.9 | 2.7 | 1614.8 | 1615.5 | 1611.1 | 12261 | 193611 | COMX |
| GOLD | Sep '11 | 1615.6 | 2.7 | 1614.3 | 1616.1 | 1612.9 | 62 | 9255 | COMX |
| GOLD | Oct '11 | 1615.8 | 2.5 | 1616.1 | 1616.4 | 1612.8 | 166 | 17547 | COMX |
| GOLD | Dec '11 | 1617.3 | 2.9 | 1616.1 | 1617.7 | 1613.4 | 4876 | 216137 | COMX |
| GOLD | Feb '12 | 1617.5 | 1.7 | 1618.0 | 1618.0 | 1617.5 | 19 | 11520 | COMX |
| GOLD | Apr '12 | 1619.4 | 2.1 | 1616.7 | 1619.4 | 1616.7 | 4 | 6165 | COMX |
Figure: Listing for COMX gold futures contracts on 25 July 2011 (Source: ifs.marketcenter.com)
| 轻质原油 (LIGHT CRUDE OIL) | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 合约 | 月份 | 最新价 | 涨跌 | 开盘 | 最高 | 最低 | 成交量 | 持仓量 | 交易所 | 日期 | 时间 |
| 轻质原油 | 2013年8月 | 101.09 | -0.15 | 101.09 | 101.49 | 100.71 | 19380 | 258114 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:38:49 |
| 轻质原油 | 2013年9月 | 100.93 | -0.18 | 100.95 | 101.31 | 100.54 | 4865 | 230505 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:38:49 |
| 轻质原油 | 2013年10月 | 99.80 | -0.26 | 99.88 | 100.18 | 99.44 | 2068 | 96887 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:24:06 |
| 轻质原油 | 2013年11月 | 98.61 | -0.36 | 98.78 | 99.05 | 98.36 | 1158 | 72866 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:05:42 |
| 轻质原油 | 2013年12月 | 97.51 | -0.39 | 97.90 | 97.93 | 97.17 | 2294 | 217091 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:22:19 |
| 轻质原油 | 2014年1月 | 96.36 | -0.49 | 96.62 | 96.68 | 96.29 | 376 | 55486 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:38:14 |
| 轻质原油 | 2014年2月 | 95.60 | -0.29 | 95.60 | 95.60 | 95.60 | 162 | 31218 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 03:19:02 |
| 轻质原油 | 2014年3月 | 94.29 | -0.76 | 94.71 | 94.71 | 94.29 | 237 | 49487 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 11:53:59 |
图:2013 年 7 月 4 日 NYMEX 原油期货合约行情(来源:ifs.marketcenter.com)
| LIGHT CRUDE OIL | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contract | Month | Last | Chg | Open | High | Low | Volume | OpenInt | Exchange | Date | Time |
| LIGHT CRUDE OIL | Aug '13 | 101.09 | -0.15 | 101.09 | 101.49 | 100.71 | 19380 | 258114 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:38:49 |
| LIGHT CRUDE OIL | Sep '13 | 100.93 | -0.18 | 100.95 | 101.31 | 100.54 | 4865 | 230505 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:38:49 |
| LIGHT CRUDE OIL | Oct '13 | 99.80 | -0.26 | 99.88 | 100.18 | 99.44 | 2068 | 96887 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:24:06 |
| LIGHT CRUDE OIL | Nov '13 | 98.61 | -0.36 | 98.78 | 99.05 | 98.36 | 1158 | 72866 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:05:42 |
| LIGHT CRUDE OIL | Dec '13 | 97.51 | -0.39 | 97.90 | 97.93 | 97.17 | 2294 | 217091 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:22:19 |
| LIGHT CRUDE OIL | Jan '14 | 96.36 | -0.49 | 96.62 | 96.68 | 96.29 | 376 | 55486 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 13:38:14 |
| LIGHT CRUDE OIL | Feb '14 | 95.60 | -0.29 | 95.60 | 95.60 | 95.60 | 162 | 31218 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 03:19:02 |
| LIGHT CRUDE OIL | Mar '14 | 94.29 | -0.76 | 94.71 | 94.71 | 94.29 | 237 | 49487 | NYME | 07/04/13 | 11:53:59 |
Figure: Listing for NYMEX crude oil futures contracts on 4 July 2013 (Source: ifs.marketcenter.com)
案例设定: COMEX 黄金期货行情(2009年2月2日):2月 $907.00,4月 $909.50,6月 $912.40,8月 $915.20,10月 $918.00,12月 $921.10。
ETQ 2 Problem Setup: Gold futures on COMEX (2 Feb 2009): Feb $907.00, Apr $909.50, Jun $912.40, Aug $915.20, Oct $918.00, Dec $921.10.
| 看涨期权 (Call) | 看跌期权 (Put) | |
|---|---|---|
| 买方(多头) | 买入的权利 | 卖出的权利 |
| 卖方(空头,立权人) | 卖出的义务 | 买入的义务 |
| Call | Put | |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer (long) | Right to buy | Right to sell |
| Writer (short) | Obligation to sell | Obligation to buy |
| 比较特征 | 远期合约 (Forwards) | 期权合约 (Options) |
|---|---|---|
| 前期成本 | 初始零现金支付 | 需立即支付期权费 (权利金) |
| 对冲性质 | 锁定完全固定的未来价格/汇率 | 提供价格保险 (设定下限底线或上限顶线) |
| 防范下行风险 | 是 (有效锁定风险) | 是 (有效对冲不利变动) |
| 分享上行收益 | 否 (上行潜在收益被完全消除) | 是 (保留上涨收益,仅扣除期权费) |
| 义务与权利 | 对交易双方均构成强制性约束 | 买方享有选择权利,卖方承担被动履约义务 |
| Feature | Forwards | Options |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | Zero initial payment | Option premium paid immediately |
| Nature of Hedge | Locks in a fixed price/rate | Provides price insurance (a floor or ceiling) |
| Downside Protection | Yes | Yes |
| Upside Participation | No (eliminated) | Yes (retained, minus premium paid) |
| Obligation vs Right | Binding obligation on both parties | Right for buyer; obligation for writer |
| 到期股票价格 | 策略 A (买入 100 股股票) | 策略 B (买入 2,000 份看涨期权) |
|---|---|---|
| 下跌至 $15 | 持仓市值 $1,500 (亏损:-$500 / -25%) | 期权价值 $0 (全额亏损:-$2,000 / -100%) |
| 上涨至 $27 | 持仓市值 $2,700 (盈利:+$700 / +35%) | 期权价值 |
| Terminal Stock Price | Strategy A (100 Shares) | Strategy B (2,000 Calls) |
|---|---|---|
| Drops to $15 | Value $1,500 (Loss: -$500 / -25%) | Value $0 (Total Loss: -$2,000 / -100%) |
| Rises to $27 | Value $2,700 (Gain: +$700 / +35%) | Value |
案例设定: ABC 有限公司股票当前价格
期权策略收益超越买入股票策略的盈亏平衡点股价:
ETQ 1 Setup: ABC Ltd stock price
Breakeven share price for Option Strategy to be more profitable:
| 现在 ( | 1 年后 ( |
|---|---|
| 以 5% 年利率借入 $1,390,期限 1 年 | 偿还贷款: |
| 以 $1,390 买入 1 盎司黄金 | 按期货合约交付黄金 |
| 以 $1,485 卖出(做空)1 年期黄金期货合约 | 收取期货价格: |
| 今日净现金流 = $0 | 套利利润 = $(1,485 − 1,459.50) = 每盎司 $25.50 |
| Now ( | After 1 year ( |
|---|---|
| Borrow $1,390 at 5% p.a. for 1 year | Repay the loan: |
| Buy 1 oz of gold for $1,390 | Deliver the gold under the futures contract |
| Short a 1-year gold futures contract at $1,485 | Receive the futures price: |
| Net cash flow today = $0 | Arbitrage profit = $(1,485 − 1,459.50) = $25.50 per oz |
| 现在 ( | 1 年后 ( |
|---|---|
| 卖出(卖空)黄金,得到 $1,390 | 按期货合约接受黄金交割 |
| 将 $1,390 按 5% 年利率投资 1 年 | 投资增长为: |
| 以 $1,390 买入 1 年期黄金期货合约(多头) | 支付期货价格: |
| 今日净现金流 = $0 | 套利利润 = $(1,459.50 − 1,390) = 每盎司 $69.50 |
| Now ( | After 1 year ( |
|---|---|
| Sell (short sell) gold for $1,390 | Take delivery of gold under the futures contract |
| Invest $1,390 at 5% p.a. for 1 year | Investment grows to |
| Long a 1-year gold futures contract at $1,390 | Pay the futures price: |
| Net cash flow today = $0 | Arbitrage profit = $(1,459.50 − 1,390) = $69.50 per oz |